Introduction: Why Repeat Orders Are the Real E-Commerce Goldmine
As an entrepreneur who’s launched and scaled multiple online stores, I can confidently say:
“Your first sale is great. Your second sale is where the profit begins.”
Most stores pour budget into paid ads and influencer marketing to get new customers, while ignoring the gold mine sitting in their existing customer list.
Also Read
The smart ones? They use CRM (Customer Relationship Management) to turn one-time buyers into repeat customers—and they do it on autopilot.
In this case study, I’ll walk you through how one e-commerce brand used CRM to increase repeat orders by 112% in just 90 days.
1. Meet the Brand: UrbanGlow Skincare
UrbanGlow is a mid-sized Shopify-based skincare brand targeting Gen Z and millennial customers. They sell eco-friendly cleansers, masks, and moisturizers.
Challenges:
- Over 65% of customers never returned after first purchase
- Email campaigns had a 9.4% open rate
- No segmentation or follow-ups after purchase
- Loyal customers weren’t being rewarded
- AOV (average order value) was stagnant
They had traffic. They had conversions. What they didn’t have was retention.
2. The Turning Point: CRM Implementation
UrbanGlow adopted Klaviyo as their CRM because of its:
- Native Shopify integration
- Behavioral segmentation
- Email/SMS automation
- Analytics dashboard with LTV and order history
Their goal: Increase reorder rate and boost LTV (Customer Lifetime Value) without increasing ad spend.
3. Step-by-Step CRM Strategy to Increase Repeat Orders
✅ Step 1: Segmentation Based on Behavior
CRM grouped customers into:
- First-time buyers
- Repeat buyers
- VIPs (spent > $250)
- Dormant (no activity in 60+ days)
Each group received different messaging, timing, and offers.
✅ Step 2: Post-Purchase Automation Flows
For first-time buyers:
- Day 2: “How to use your new product”
- Day 5: Review request + user-generated content
- Day 10: “Other products you’ll love”
- Day 15: Discount on second purchase
For repeat buyers:
- “We appreciate your loyalty—here’s early access to new drops.”
Result: Second order rate jumped by 46% just from this flow.
✅ Step 3: Smart Product Recommendations
Using CRM’s data:
- Customers who bought face wash were suggested moisturizer
- Those who bought masks got emailed about serums
- AI tracked pairings to maximize relevance
Open rates doubled when emails included “based on what you love” products.
✅ Step 4: Reactivation Campaign for Inactive Customers
Segment: No orders in 60+ days.
CRM flow:
- “We miss you” email with personalized picks
- 10% off next order + free shipping
- FOMO social proof: “Over 12,000 people reordered last month!”
Conversion rate: 14.7% from reactivation flow alone.
✅ Step 5: VIP Program & Loyalty Ladder
Tracked by CRM, customers were tagged based on:
- Total spent
- Purchase frequency
- Review activity
Then:
- Bronze: 2+ purchases → 5% loyalty coupon
- Silver: 4+ purchases → early access
- Gold: 6+ → gifts + exclusive products
Result: VIPs had 4.8x the LTV of regular buyers.
4. Results After 90 Days
| Metric | Before CRM | After CRM |
|---|---|---|
| Repeat Purchase Rate | 18.9% | 40.1% |
| Email Open Rate | 9.4% | 28.6% |
| Email Revenue (monthly) | $2,300 | $7,450 |
| Average Order Value (AOV) | $38.20 | $45.10 |
| Recovered Inactive Customers | — | 1,740 |
| Customer Lifetime Value (LTV) | $81.35 | $172.90 |
5. Tools Used in Their CRM Stack
| Tool | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Klaviyo | CRM + email/SMS automation |
| Shopify | Storefront + order sync |
| Smile.io | Loyalty points and tier tracking |
| Loox | Product reviews and user content |
| Facebook Ads | Lookalike campaigns for loyal buyers |
6. Lessons Learned (That You Can Copy Today)
✅ Start small—1–2 email flows can already double reorders
✅ Segment deeply—never blast everyone with the same offer
✅ Focus on the second sale—it’s the start of customer loyalty
✅ Reward repeat customers early—not just your biggest spenders
✅ Automate what you can and track everything
7. Common Mistakes to Avoid
| Mistake | Better Approach |
|---|---|
| Using one list for all emails | Segment by behavior, value, and time since last purchase |
| No post-purchase communication | Build email/SMS flows right after order is placed |
| Forgetting dormant customers | Set up reactivation flows |
| No loyalty program or tiers | Reward frequency—not just high spend |
| Blind to ROI | Use CRM dashboards to track retention campaigns |
8. Metrics You Must Monitor
CRM allows you to track:
- Repeat customer rate
- LTV by segment
- Reorder interval (time between purchases)
- Email revenue by flow
- Abandoned cart recovery rate
- VIP conversion trends
Data drives growth—CRM brings visibility.
Conclusion: CRM = More Customers Coming Back, More Often
Here’s the deal:
If you’re spending more to get new customers than you are to keep the ones you have—you’re building a leaky bucket.
CRM fills that bucket.
With it, you get:
- Personalization
- Automation
- Loyalty
- Data-driven decision making
UrbanGlow’s results weren’t a fluke. They were the outcome of a system—and you can build the same.
So ask yourself:
What’s your repeat customer rate? What could it be with CRM?
It’s time to find out.
